The Lifestylists

Rejected by eHarmony

Posted Mon, Jun 29, 2009
POST A COMMENT »

So I've been single now for over a month. And though I hadn't really thought about getting back into the dating game, I was making dinner last night and heard a commercial for eHarmony. After several adorable and perfectly matched couples shared their stories of finding true love via this online matchmaker, the commercial wooed me with, 'Sign up now and check your matches for free!Broken heart(Getty)

I like free stuff as much as the next single lady, so I got onto eHarmony, registered and then began filling out THE LONGEST QUESTIONNAIRE of all time: 436 questions that range from things like your religious background to whether you smoke to how clean your room is to whether your mate's physical appearance is important to you, etc. I joked later with my brother (who had also signed up) that I don't think I care enough about who I'm going to date to laboriously answer an almost 500 question survey.

So after 45 minutes of applying random scaled numbers to questions like, 'How in control of your life do you feel?' (there was no negative number options) to, 'Are you a happy person?' (sober?), I finally completed this behemoth and was ready to meet my matches.

Then I get an emotional punch in the gut from eHarmony. After giving almost an hour of my time and energy to this process, I get a message that reads, 'Unable to match you at this time.' Then there's a whole lot of 'it's not you it's me' nonsense and how the service actually won't work for 1 in every 5 users because they 'are so convinced of the importance of creating compatible matches that [they] sometimes choose not to provide service rather than risk an uncertain match.' Wow, thanks eHarmony.

Talk about getting kicked while you're down. I wasn't even outta the 'dating' gates yet and already I'm in last place. I still feel like there's a stigma attached to online dating, and for people who are possibly using this site a last resort to find love, getting rejected by the matchmaker is going make most forlorn singles cry themselves to sleep with a bottle of merlot in hand. Seriously, it was quite a blow to my self-esteem that I'm not fit to date even one of the millions of people registered for their site. (And my dream of starring in one of those tooth-achingly sweet commercial where I dance around a loft and fawn over my new beau has been crushed!)

So why the rejection? Thoughts are mixed. Some say if you list yourself as married or separated or married more than twice, if you're under 20, if you seem mentally or emotionally unstable (based on how you answered certain questions) or seemingly not ready for a long term, committed, monogamous relationship you'll get the big fat R from eHarmony.

I'm not sure where I fit in this list. I'm in my 20s and I've never been married or separated (jury's still out my mental and emotional stability!). But I said I wasn't looking for marriage right away, and that could have been the clincher. But after doing some research, I realized most people who get rejected from eHarmony never really find out why they didn't make the cut.

Ah well, a little rejection on the path to find true love is inevitable, no?

Have you tried eHarmony? Have you been rejected? Do you use online dating sites? And which one do you think is best?

- Vanessa 

Average (8 Ratings)4.14 out of 5 stars

20 Comments

  • 1. Posted by shannlen on Mon, Jun 29, 2009

    After being single for 12 years (and loving it), I had recently moved to a new city and started to use lavalife to find dates and friends. Sept. 11th happened and I realized what I really wanted was a long-term partner. We met in November after one exchange on lavalife and we have been together ever since.

    Report Abuse
  • 2. Posted by megawatt on Mon, Jun 29, 2009

    Thank God!!!! I am not the only one rejected by E-Harmony! You put it very succinctly, it was definitely an emotional punch in the gut! I've been on Plenty of Fish since that time and although I have yet to find my soul-mate, at least I didn't get the same kind of rejection that came from a website you have to PAY for!

    Report Abuse
  • 3. Posted by Sekino on Mon, Jun 29, 2009

    That's weird, I registered with eHarmony 2.5 years ago: I wasn't decided yet, I just wanted to check out their big quiz and how it worked. I thought one wouldn't get contacts unless one paid so I didn't think I would get people contacting me. I was shocked when I got 15 requests from other members wanting to communicate. I didn't even PAY! I quickly found the way to 'switch' the account to 'no communication'. So for me, it seemed to work, but it wasn't that great since most 'prospects' lived hundreds of miles away (so the geography doesn't seem to be a factor, which is dumb). Turns out that a year later, I met my guy on the bus commute to work. So in my experience, a great dating service is common transportation ;)

    Report Abuse
  • 4. Posted by NEIL C on Mon, Jun 29, 2009

    Try Plentyoffish.com, it's free and they won't reject you as long as you don't post any porn of yourself on the site.

    Report Abuse
  • 5. Posted by J C on Mon, Jun 29, 2009

    POF should be changed to POD - Plenty of Dreamers If you want to continue getting kicked in the gut spend some time on that site. ( or any other internet dating site for that matter) Net dating was allot different when it 1st started. Yes it shrunk the world and provided some fairy tale endings. Now it seems the bulk of people on there are looking for way more than they can offer. Example: the not so desirable type looking for their hot movie star match. Or the decent looking person who posts get so many messages they don't know where to start. Then there are those who think you can tell something about someone by a short blurb on who they say they are. I could list a 1000 things. Most things run full circle, I notice i get more smiles during daily life than online. Heck a few of those live smiler's were one's who wouldn't give me the time of day online.

    Report Abuse
  • 6. Posted by T on Mon, Jun 29, 2009

    My mom and step-dad met on Planetultimate, but I don't think it exists anymore.

    Report Abuse
  • 7. Posted by J C on Mon, Jun 29, 2009

    POF should be changed to POD - Plenty of Dreamers If you want to continue getting kicked in the gut spend some time on that site. ( or any other internet dating site for that matter) Net dating was allot different when it 1st started. Yes it shrunk the world and provided some fairy tale endings. Now it seems the bulk of people on there are looking for way more than they can offer. Example: the not so desirable type looking for their hot movie star match. Or the decent looking person who posts get so many messages they don't know where to start. Then there are those who think you can tell something about someone by a short blurb on who they say they are. I could list a 1000 things. Most things run full circle, I notice i get more smiles during daily life than online. Heck a few of those live smiler's were one's who wouldn't give me the time of day online.

    Report Abuse
  • 8. Posted by sask on Tue, Jun 30, 2009

    I also got rejected by EHarmony because I was separated but I tried to see if I could change it to divorced when I got divorced and it wouldnt let me, wasnt impressed. I have used POF and met some very nice people on there, but of course, met some not so nice ones as well, nothing is perfect, but after all that I met my man in the bar, of all places, and Im very happy, so I guess the old fashioned way still works. Good luck everyone.

    Report Abuse
  • 9. Posted by Marcelerated on Tue, Jun 30, 2009

    Rumour has it that you'll be rejected by eHarmony if you identify yourself as an atheist or an agnostic. Which, in the Great Protestant nation to our south, is pretty much the exact amount (i.e. 1 in 5).

    Report Abuse
  • 10. Posted by focus nicky on Tue, Jun 30, 2009

    I did not get rejected by EH but I am having the issue of them sending me matches that are NOT what I am looking for at all! They ask what you want and I get the ones I don't want. I have tried the lavalife, POF, match.com, and even soulmates to no avail. All I get are those ones who are looking to get lucky and not for a serious relationship. It sucks!

    Report Abuse
  • 11. Posted by Clarence on Tue, Jun 30, 2009

    eHarmony deals with people, not lollipops. You wouldn't know it though the way most guys expect the girls (who have clearly stated that they want to proceed slowly) to get busy. Either way, no-one is entitled to anything when it comes to relationships. Love is a gift not a right. If there's no match, try to be happy that at least the computer isn't trying to lead you down the path of fools. Coed sports is a nice way to meet cuties in person. It's better that way.

    Report Abuse
  • 12. Posted by bird b on Tue, Jun 30, 2009

    Ok so one night I couldn't sleep so I registered at E-Harmony as well. Same thing after wasting my time for an hour at 2am I was also rejected for being separated (it did tell me why I did not qualify), so why can't it tell you in question 2 that you don't make the cut, instead you waste everyones time. So ok next night still can't sleep so I re-register but cheat and say I'm divorced lol. In the questionnaire I request men age 39 - 50, living in my area. Almost immediately I start getting numerous e-mails of their selected "matches", again they waste my time as all in age group of 55-60 and living 75 miles away, what the hell. E-Harmony I reject you and shut you @ss off....

    Report Abuse
  • 13. Posted by OneEyedMartini on Wed, Jul 01, 2009

    E-HarmAny.... Need I say more?

    Report Abuse
  • 14. Posted by OneEyedMartini on Wed, Jul 01, 2009

    Sorry I guess I clicked 1 too many times on send

    Report Abuse
  • 15. Posted by Lindz on Wed, Jul 01, 2009

    It takes 24hours to get your first matches everyone gets that they should say that because I bet a lot of people don't check back after the first rejection. but you still gotta pay to meet or talk to those matches

    Report Abuse
  • 16. Posted by gloopax on Wed, Jul 01, 2009

    I was rejected after wasting an hour filling out the questionnaire because I was only separated. That is about question #2. eHarmony owes me an hour of my life back. Fix your stupid questionnaire so as not to waste people's time.

    Report Abuse
  • 17. Posted by Cowgirl for real.. and ever on Wed, Jul 01, 2009

    E-H wants money- their way and only their way. Sucks to be you, thought it was " judge not lest ye be judged." Dang it.

    Report Abuse
  • 18. Posted by svetlonos on Wed, Jul 01, 2009

    After about a month, I realized that Eharmony is just a marriage broker. It's probably not a bad service for "normal" people looking for a "normal" partner for a "normal" marriage, but for me it seemed unreal, and I really felt trapped. Much of the laborious questionnaire at the beginning seemed vague and empty, but what really bothered me about it is the way they severely restrict communication between people. I would really recommend okcupid.com. It's free and filled with questions and tests about yourself, which are actually interesting and entertaining. The tests range from "Where are you on the political spectrum?" to "What Transformers character are you?" to "What do you know about art?", and most of the questions are written by the users, so they tend to be about real, definite issues. There are also forums where you can discuss the questions with other users and post your own topic for discussion. It's kind of a combination of a matchmaker and Facebook. I find myself there quite often, just because the tests are fun.

    Report Abuse
  • 19. Posted by svetlonos on Wed, Jul 01, 2009

    After about a month, I realized that Eharmony is just a marriage broker. It's probably not a bad service for "normal" people looking for a "normal" partner for a "normal" marriage, but for me it seemed unreal, and I really felt trapped. Much of the laborious questionnaire at the beginning seemed vague and empty, but what really bothered me about it is the way they severely restrict communication between people. I would really recommend okcupid.com. It's free and filled with questions and tests about yourself, which are actually interesting and entertaining. The tests range from "Where are you on the political spectrum?" to "What Transformers character are you?" to "What do you know about art?", and most of the questions are written by the users, so they tend to be about real, definite issues. There are also forums where you can discuss the questions with other users and post your own topic for discussion. It's kind of a combination of a matchmaker and Facebook. I find myself there quite often, just because the tests are fun.

    Report Abuse
  • 20. Posted by GoodIdea on Mon, Jul 20, 2009

    Rejected by eHarmony, lol. You can try match.com, it's just as good imo. And btw, there is nothing wrong with online dating and (in person) matchmaking services. They help you meet people you might have never met and it's important to meet enough people so you find someone you like and someone who likes you. I met my wife of 11 years through a matchmaking service, I don't consider myself desperate at all, I just didn't want to wait my entire life to find someone to spend my life with.

    Report Abuse

LEAVE YOUR COMMENT
character(s) remaining

You must sign in to leave a comment

TODAY ON YAHOO!

Business

A man walks past a company sign at a Nortel Networks office tower in Toronto. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nathan Denette


Ericsson, Kapsch to buy, split up Nortel's GSM business units
The Canadian Press - TORONTO - LM Ericsson and another European company have been selected to...

Sports

Soccer-CSKA Moscow v VfL Wolfsburg - teams
Reuters - MOSCOW, Nov 25 (Reuters) - Teams for Wednesday's Champions League Group B match between...

Odd News

A first edition of Charles Darwin's groundbreaking Origin Of Species. (THE ASSOCIATED PRESS /Christie's, ho)


The Origin of Thievery? UK says crooks took Charles Darwin's cherished leather-bound journal
The Canadian Press - LONDON - British authorities say they're searching for a leather-bound...