My Messy Bedroom

I Kid You Not

Posted Fri, Aug 01, 2008
POST A COMMENT »

I've never had any burning urge to reproduce. There's no family pressure and plenty of grandkids, even great grandkids, from the other siblings. And after spending two days at our cottage with a friend?s rugrats quelled my urge even more.

I admire women who have always known they would have kids, no question. But I also admire the ones who have always known they would not. Like my friend Karen, now in her 40s, she knew by her mid-20s that she never wanted kids and got her tubes tied at 31. "I could not see bringing yet another child into this messed up world," she says. "If I did want kids, I'd prefer to adopt a child who needed a home, rather than create another human being."

Frankly, I wish people with kids had to defend their position as thoroughly as those who don't want children. Because, heaven knows, some folks are having kids for the wrong reasons. Say, to have someone to take care of them when they're older. But, chances are your partner and/or your friends will be more reliable in old age than some kid who will no doubt grow up and move to Australia.

Another argument is that people who don't have children are selfish. And your point is? Yes, I like the freedom to work and enjoy life with just little old me to think about. Besides, give me a break. Why do you think people have kids? To further the human race? For the kid's sake? Doubtful. Usually, it's just the thing to do. Or, as Karen says, to create the ultimate accessory. "It's typically women who are oohing and ahhing over all things baby, the teensy clothes/shoes -- 'oh isn't this adorable?' -- photos, all the nursery stuff. It's like a commodity."

Sure, some people have kids because they genuinely like them but there are plenty of folks who don't. The last big grief people who choose not to have kids hear: you'll regret it. There are plenty of things I could regret if I let myself. But I certainly don't want to have a kid just in case I regret not having one. Karen says she hasn't regretted her decision for one second. "If I feel the desire to be around children, I have my sister's kids -- and remember, I don't hate the little buggers in the least!"

 Okay, let me say it too. I enjoy kids, sort of. I like the fun stuff but I'm always ready to hand them back after an hour or so. New mothers always say it's different with your own. But what if it's not? You can't toss 'em back. Obviously, we have some genetic disposition to reproduce or the race would have ended long ago. But it's not for everyone. And I don't want to feel inadequate or less of a complete woman for not popping out a kid. We make childbearing so noble, such an achievement, like it's the most exciting, fulfilling thing you can do. For some, I'm sure it is. But, given our social bias, deciding not to have a child is an equally noble and difficult decision. And that, I think, deserves a cigar.

No Kidding is an international organization that offers child-free support services and info. For info, go to nokidding.net.

Average (291 Ratings)4 out of 5 stars

  • 1. Posted by joedeci@ymail.com on Fri, Aug 01, 2008

    Alright I dont want to be one of these posters who over reacts to things. And I agree with the 'tone' of this article - you shouldn't be judged on your decision to have kids or to not have kids, it's you (and your partners') own personal choice. And I do agree that there should be some sort of reproducability test that one needs to take before having kids. However, I do find the "Usually it's just the thing to do" comment to be off-base and dismissive. It may be for some but usually implies most and I think that's way off.

    Report Abuse
  • 2. Posted by Evamom on Wed, Aug 06, 2008

    Actually checking out the website, nokidding.net, there's alot more of the "having kids means getting into a whole mess" tone. The article makes a good point that those who don't want children should not be made to feel like weirdos, but that's as far as it goes.

    Report Abuse
  • 3. Posted by Katu on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    Wonderful article. It expresses the sentiment that some (acutally a lot, in my generation) women feel these days. Your life CAN be fullfiling without reproducing. This is something I feel older women (mothers and grandmothers) need to relalize before they start pressuring the younger generations.

    Report Abuse
  • 4. Posted by Lex on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    Kids aren't for everyone and if only more people who didn't want them realized before they had them the world would probably be a much happier place.

    Report Abuse
  • 5. Posted by missdustyrose on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I find this article extremely hypocritical, you are saying that you dont want to be judged on not having kids and yet saying that woman that ooh and aww over baby clothes are only having them as accessories? whose judging who?? I think bringing a life into this world is the most beautiful noble thing you can do.

    Report Abuse
  • 6. Posted by tbat on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    Finally, someone who sees things my way! I'm sure I'm not the only one. I love kids and all the little buggers in my family get the best gifts from me but I don't want any myself and yeah, a lot of people (mostly women) think I'm selfish for it, but I don't care. The way I see it: what's my choice is mine, what's theirs is theirs... Many women (with kids, no kidding) have told me that I will change my mind and I'm 29, still not looking back!

    Report Abuse
  • 7. Posted by ampagresta on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    LOVE this article!

    Report Abuse
  • 8. Posted by firebreather on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I'm with the author. I've never wanted kids. I'm 47 and still don't want them. Being a woman in this day and age means that should be ok. I also expect that people who do have children would do so mindfully and carefully. I see a lot of accidents happening, all around me. I see a laissez-faire attitude to child rearing, including allowing children to do whatever the hell they feel like. As a result, it's not hard to see that today's teens are increasingly belligerent and spoiled. There are exceptions, but they ARE EXCEPTIONS. Too many of us are intent on satisfying the social order and doing as we've always done. Think of what you're doing. I'm sure some do, but I've seen far too much evidence to the contrary.

    Report Abuse
  • 9. Posted by finlorie on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I'm with you, Josey Vogels! Like your friend Karen, I made the decision early not to have children and now, in my 50s, have no regrets about the choice. Children can be wonderful, for parents who want them, but there are far too many children "out there" who are clearly unwanted, judging by the abuse and neglect they suffer. It should not be necessary to defend a decision to go through life without having children -- and, no, many of us DON'T regret that choice. I'm all in favour of people choosing to have children, and just hope that there's another baby boom to ensure that we have enough workers paying into the various social programs!

    Report Abuse
  • 10. Posted by kuiporng on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    if you don't have kids, you can never express the kind of love you can only express to your own children... never....

    Report Abuse
  • 11. Posted by m_ihasz on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    Thank you, thank you, thank you. I'm 26 and I've always known I don't want children. Don't like them and I don't want them, never have and never will. Your right, people are constantly saying that I'll change my mind.. just wait. Well no I won't. I am selfish and I like my freedom. I know this and I'm not trying to pretend otherwise.

    Report Abuse
  • 12. Posted by knuttley on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I don't know about you but in the work world non kidders are constantly discriminated against. When it comes down to a lay off and you do not have a union, employers will keep the guy with the family nine times out of ten unless he is a total screw up.

    Report Abuse
  • 13. Posted by Nexus on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    Great article. I'm a man and constantly face accusing questions about my decision not to get married or have kids. I can only imagine how much more difficult it is for women to defend their decision. Kids are incredibly expensive and require at least a 25 year commitment. For some, that time and money can be better used in other ways. I wish people didn't need to be so judgemental about it. It takes all kinds to make the world an interesting place. Let everyone make their own decision and respect it.

    Report Abuse
  • 14. Posted by goodkarma on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I actually would believe her, but after reading the article she sounds selfish and in complete disregard of reality of the need for raising children in this world. I always get a kick out of "give them back after an hour", or the " I will adopt" . It really is another excuse....I would like to have the same previledge and thought process with my partner, unfortunately it doesnt work this way for some reason...

    Report Abuse
  • 15. Posted by esperanta6 on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    this is so timely.. there was a time when feminism was about not having children and having a "serious" job.. but now i fear the pendulum has shifted and the new wave (mind you mostly white middle class) feminists are all about motherhood. Enough is enough.. why can't we have more of a balance and exercise some choice in the matter?

    Report Abuse
  • 16. Posted by knuttley on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I don't know about you but in the work world non kidders are constantly discriminated against. When it comes down to a lay off and you do not have a union, employers will keep the guy with the family nine times out of ten unless he is a total screw up.

    Report Abuse
  • 17. Posted by mcleigh. on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    Not sure why we anyone feels the need to justify their decision to have or not have kids. It's your life, isn't it? I have four. Also, I have recently returned to university and spend a lot of time ducking disapproving looks about that -- earth's overpopulated etc. I sort of think it's nobody's business but my own -- my kids'll be keeping the world running 20 years from now when this overpoluated earth also has to deal with an inverse median age. Do what you want -- both sides can be argued, why bother? Argue I -ha!

    Report Abuse
  • 18. Posted by mustangguy_ca on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I must say. THANK YOU to the author of this excellent blog, I only wish more people would adopt the child free attitude.

    Report Abuse
  • 19. Posted by sleepyhead on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    Love the article! I have to agree with many of the things she's saying mainly because I know many people who have children for the reasons she gives. I know someone who's procreated to have people look after them once they're old, and I know of another who's had kids because it was something to do... Everyone does what works for them, but it would be nice if people actually brought children into the world because they were dedicated in raising a contributing member to society rather than a pass time. If that's the case, get a hobby!

    Report Abuse
  • 20. Posted by nexteljr8 on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    Ha! I agree with this article and enjoy my freedom and being selfish! Every weekend I hang out on a beach with my friends and guess what happens to my friends that have kids, they disappear forever! The comment about "when their your own kids it's different", what else is a parent supposed to say, having kids sucks, don't do it???

    Report Abuse
  • 21. Posted by Gord on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    Thank you so much for writing this article. I've been saying much the same for years, constantly defending myself against the "it's so selfish not to have kids" crowd, when in fact it seemed to me so many people had kids for nothing but selfish reasons.

    Report Abuse
  • 22. Posted by Janey on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I think this position is getting a lot more air-time these days, which is good. It's good to think about why we do things, instead of doing them just because. And I applaud you for not choosing to have a child for a bunk-o reason (like so they will take care of you in your old age, or b/c it would be "unthinkable" not to). It's like you care enough about the unborn child to not bring it here when there's a chance that you'd be ambivalent about the whole thing. And I have no doubt that you're right about the idea that those who have kids should have to thoroughly defend the decision. Because there are a lot of people out there who hide behind their kids, from a myriad of things.

    Report Abuse
  • 23. Posted by helenrosicki1 on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    ok this is my take, kids are not a thing to like or dislike childern are a reflection of the parent and society so alot that you see you do not like is about you. Childern are the future, they are brilliant perfect humans until adults screw them up with no discipline, fear so on. I am a mother My son never once take from my life only added knowledge wisdom and growth

    Report Abuse
  • 24. Posted by Kim L on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I completely agree with Josey regarding having to defend your decision. My husband and I decided to have one child. It always amazes me how many people think they should quiz me on when the next one is coming, tell me that it isn't right to just have one that he needs a sibbling, it's child abuse to only have one, one kid isn't really having kids, etc, etc, etc. I would never quiz someone with several children as to why they didn't stop at one. Besides being ridiculous, it is just plain rude, and nobody's business except the people involved.

    Report Abuse
  • 25. Posted by woodrunner1 on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    Verry good, I see in this article a woman who is not confident enough to have kids or maby just selfish(it's all about me kind of woman)eighter way,it'better if thoes kind of person don't have childrens. If there was less people thinking like this,the world would be a mutch more pleasant place to live in. I'll have a cigar to that! lol

    Report Abuse
  • 26. Posted by sylviatheend on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    "I could not see bringing yet another child into this messed up world," she says. "If I did want kids, I'd prefer to adopt a child who needed a home, rather than create another human being." OK BUT ONCE YOU HAVE KIDS YOUR DESIRE TO FIX THINGS UP GROWS A WHOLE LOT MORE SINCE SOMEONE U LOVE WILL GET THIS WORLD AFTER,

    Report Abuse
  • 27. Posted by Eccentric_da... on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I for one am the one who really wanted children. I remember being very young and wishing I had a baby, the dollies worked for me. I am now a 43 year old mother who had it tough as a kid growing up in a very dysfunctional family. I for one wanted to be the best mom mainly because my own mother should never have been aloud to have any. Saying that I have 2, some what stable, children that actually lived to be adults. My eldest is married and has chosen not to have a family, disappointing as it is for me I understand her decision and support her.

    Report Abuse
  • 28. Posted by Lisa K on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I just celebrated one year after getting my tubes tied!! I have no regrets about my decision. People should put a lot of thought into having, or not having, kids, and not bow to societal pressures.

    Report Abuse
  • 29. Posted by coey on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    This article expresses what I've been trying to tell people my whole life, about my decision not to have kids. So glad to know people feel the same way I do!!! Thanks!

    Report Abuse
  • 30. Posted by MelKat on Thu, Aug 07, 2008

    I couldn't agree more. I knew since before puberty I was never going to have kids....I simply have zero interest in children. Now, at age 36, I've had myself "fixed". I have no temperment for children, and in general really don't like them...why would I have one just because someone tells me I should?

    Report Abuse

LEAVE YOUR COMMENT
character(s) remaining

You must sign in to leave a comment

TODAY ON YAHOO!

Business

Canadian Auto Workers President Buzz Hargrove talks with media after a meeting with General Motors executives in Detroit, in early July THE CANADIAN PRESS/Dave Chidley


Economy cranks out 15,200 jobs in August, but shakiness persists
The Canadian Press - OTTAWA - Canada's economy exhibited signs of coming back to life in...

Entertainment

Soderbergh film on Che Guevara has world premier in Spain
AFP - MADRID (AFP) - "The Argentine", a new movie by Oscar-winning US director Steven Soderberg...

Odd News

Damsel in distress turns out to be caged cokatoo practising vocabulary
The Canadian Press - TRENTON, N.J. - Cries for help inside a Trenton, N.J., home turned out to be...