Daycare desperation

Posted Thu, May 15, 2008
POST A COMMENT »

Tales of daycare desperation have been making the rounds on both sides of the border this past week.

First, there was a story out of Winnipeg reporting that an area daycare director had asked parents in the area to stop harassing members of her staff about the centre's waiting list for spaces. Then, researchers from Cornell University revealed that large numbers of American parents (20 to 40 per cent of parents who use childcare on a week-to-week basis) were relying on a patchwork quilt of different childcare arrangements in order to cover off their family's childcare needs from week to week.

The Winnipeg daycare story ended up making headline news across the country. Karen Ohlson, executive director of the K.I.D.S. Inc daycare at Winnipeg's Montrose School, told CBC News that parents, frustrated by long waiting lists for daycare spaces at the centre, had been harassing members of her staff and questioning the integrity of the centre's waiting list procedures. Ohlson urged parents to voice their concerns about the city's daycare shortage to elected officials rather than taking out their frustrations on members of her staff.

The Cornell University study — which was published in the May issue of the Journal of Marriage and Family — didn't attract quite as much attention, but its findings were no less newsworthy. Taryn W. Morrissey of Cornell University's Department of Human Development concluded that "the mismatch between [early childhood education] program hours, availability and parents' employment schedules results in families coordinating several child-care arrangements over a single day or week." She noted that earlier research indicates that experiencing multiple arrangements negatively affects children's social adjustment and that coordinating transportation and hours among different childcare arrangements may contribute to parents' stress and "poor employment outcomes." In other words, it takes more time and energy to juggle two childcare arrangements than to manage one.

Now over to you: If you've struggled to find childcare for your children, you understand the stress that the Cornell Study is talking about — and that led to the situation in Winnipeg. So my question for you is this: what can we do as a society to deal with the childcare crisis that parents across the country are facing?

Related:

Not Yet Rated

6 Comments

  • 1. Posted by Mia T on Sun, May 18, 2008

    Your timing of this post could not be more apt! When my daughter was one and I had to go back to work I was very lucky to find someone who was wonderful. Our daycare provider loves my daughter as she does her own children. Two years later I am looking again...can one hit gold twice? As parents we stuggle and struggle. I live with some much worry and guilt everyday. Searching for daycare is actually invading my everyday. I don't sleep I don't eat. People would say I overreact, but really this is the health and happiness of my two year old! It's so hard to find someone who has a spot, and shares the same parentig values I do. I've considered a center but my daughter's been so sick over the past few years it's just not feasible! Here I am backed into a corner again. It seems to me that familes in this country and the people who care for them (daycare providers and teachers) and really respected. I leave you with these few questions...why do most centers start taking babies at 18mths but mat. leave ends at 12 months? Why does good childcare cost up to $75 a day? Why are there so few part time spots? Why do parents have to lie to take a day off with their sick child? Where is the support in terms of flex hours/days etc....other countries have mandates about 1/2 time options, flex days sick leaves for kids....no support

    Report Abuse
  • 2. Posted by anndouglas on Sat, May 24, 2008

    Mia, I wish I had the answers to those questions. I know large numbers of parents have been asking those very same types of questions for as long as I have been a parent -- 20 years! And, where I live, parents at one school are speaking out angrily about a proposal to change the school day start time to 9:20 am. As a parent who tries to juggle work/daycare, you know what a huge curve-ball that is to throw in the laps of an entire school community. Sometimes I wonder how "the people in charge" can be so out of touch with the needs of real parents. It is shocking and infuriating to me as a mother and a taxpayer. I am encouraged, however, to see some grassroots protests organized by groups of parents who are refusing to be placated by token "consultations". They want a real voice in changes that have far-reaching consequences for their families. Politicians and public officials would be wise to wake up and sense the changing mood amongst parents. They are sick of being stuck between a rock and a hard place -- and then being blamed for not finding solutions to "their" childcare problems. What I hear parents saying is enough is enough.

    Report Abuse
  • 3. Posted by Jason on Wed, May 28, 2008

    Canada has to get back to it's "roots" of families looking after their own children. I live in Asia and over here it's done the old way. Grandparents live in the same home or nearby and look after the little ones, or mothers have their own small shop and the little kids area at "work" with mom. Canadians have been led astray by big BIG government, having mom AND dad go off to work so that BOTH can pay taxes and big ol' government can "take care" of everyone. Say "NO" to the nanny state. Create your own income from home. It's not hard anymore due to the Internet.

    Report Abuse
  • 4. Posted by sylvanfire on Wed, May 28, 2008

    I know from my friend who owns her own home daycare that it's hard to cater to everyone in need. She has one kid being dropped off at 6:30am... and the last kid leaves at 6... that's a 12 hour day, because unlike everyone else who work's an office job she can't take 15 minute breaks and hour lunches. If she tries to have a holiday all her parents complain that she's not open, and where they are going to put their kids, and it's hard because our daycare providers are SEVERELY underpaid making and average of $160/week/kid... so in a home daycare she can only have 5 children at once, being she has her own child she counts as 1... so that's 4 kids... 640 a week... and 2560 a month. But now she needs to pay to feed the kids, diapers(if their in them), equipment upkeep, morgage payments, insurance, and of course she doesn't have medical because she's "self employed". You can't complain that the people providing your care aren't trying, it's their support network that sucks! To ask them to try and take part time kids requires one of those spots to still be used... if parents wanting parttime found another parent wanting the off hours then they probably would but you forget that they still need to survive. You can't ask a care worker to push her bounds because although your family is important her's is more! They don't ever get raises... so appreciate your care worker! They're people who try everything they can... they need your help, as you need theirs!

    Report Abuse
  • 5. Posted by anndouglas on Wed, May 28, 2008

    Our childcare providers are definitely underpaid. Even childcare providers who work in licensed childcare facilities (both non-profit and for-profit) rarely make a living wage. For a huge roundup of childcare studies and stats, visit http://www.childcarecanada.org Working from home isn't always everything that it's cracked up to be. It isn't easy to juggle work and family -- and you have to generate significant revenues to pay yourself a living wage. It's important to get the facts about what self-employment is really like (the good, the bad, and the ugly) in order to know if starting your own business is a good option for you and your family. Your local small business self-help center and other parent-entrepreneurs (and former parent-entrepreneurs) should be able to give you the lowdown on what self-employment is all about. Don't just rely on the very optimistic magazine success stories that make it seem super easy. It's hard work. Mia T: Thanks for your thoughtful post. I agree: we need to stand together rather than trashing one another's choices.

    Report Abuse
  • 6. Posted by whitmania@rogers.com on Mon, Jun 02, 2008

    Did you have kids to raise them yourself or to let someone else do it? If you want childcare, your children should be in your care.

    Report Abuse

LEAVE YOUR COMMENT
character(s) remaining

You must sign in to leave a comment

TODAY ON YAHOO!

Top stories

Rapper DMX arrested at Phoenix mall on felony charge of ID theft
The Canadian Press - PHOENIX - Rapper DMX has been arrested at a Phoenix mall on a felony charge...

Entertainment

UK pop star enjoys new life as hit songwriter
Reuters - NEW YORK (Billboard) - UK Singer/songwriter Cathy Dennis stormed America at the...

Odd News

A woman being attacked by a kangaroo is saved by her pet dog
The Canadian Press - SYDNEY, Australia - An elderly woman was attacked by a large kangaroo on a...