Yahoo! Parenting

Crazy talk

Posted Fri, Feb 22, 2008
POST A COMMENT »

"Parents want a fast solution. They don't want to drive the kid to counselling every week. So the doctor pulls out his prescription pad..."

Oh, really?

I don't know about you, but that comment from Gordon Floyd simply doesn't ring true with me. Floyd is executive director of Children's Mental Health Ontario and made the comment to The Globe and Mail's Carolyn Abraham in her article this past weekend about the use of powerful psychiatric medications by young children.

You see, the parents I know who have navigated the mental health system with their children aren't exactly the type to go for the quick fix. They're resourceful and resilient, not because they are some sort of saintly breed of Supermoms and Superdads, but because that's what's required to advocate for your child within the child-youth mental health system in this country, particularly if you live outside a major city.

So what's with the retro "just blame mom and dad" attitude? If parents are unable to connect their kids with the types of services that they need, it's because of waiting lists or a shortage of services, not because the parents simply couldn't be bothered to take junior to a counselling appointment.

To be fair, Floyd acknowledges that there are other problems with the mental health system in Ontario - that there aren't the resources to provide intensive talk or cognitive therapy to the kids who need it. Who can argue with that? But when it comes to assigning blame, he's a little too quick to pin the blame on the very people who are already feeling bashed and battered by the child-youth mental health system in this country Mom and Dad.

Let me tell you a story about a mother whose child was going through a desperate time. She worried that things would never get better for her or her child. Sometimes she wondered if her child would ever grow up to be a young adult. She turned to the mental health system in her town, only to discover that it didn't have one — only something mirage-like that showed up on government flowcharts and funding diagrams, but that disappeared if real people got too close. One day a kindly police officer took that mother aside and gave her The Big Talk about the mental health facts of life. "If your child runs into trouble, head into the city. There is no mental health system for kids in this town."

Once the mother knew the truth, she felt free to stop letting her life and her child's life be ruled by the frustrating and arbitrary rules dictated by a system that wasn't really there in the first place. Her child grew healthier and stronger and the mother dared to start breathing and living her own life again. And the entire family got on with the business of being a family. I know because I was — I am — that mother.

Now over to you: What are your thoughts about the child-youth mental health system in this country? Do you feel that there's room for improvement?

Related articles:

Not Yet Rated

1 Comment

  • 1. Posted by Mia T on Fri, Feb 22, 2008

    While he may be off when saying that parents want the quick fix, I don't know how wrong he is in his belief that doctors just pull out a prescription pad,although I'm sure not all doctors do). A quick story of my own. Once I had a student who I thought had a processing issue- this something that cannot be identified in a school. I suggested the parents talk to their doctor for a referal and look into it. Within a week the student was acting very strange in class, behaviours he had never demonstrated before. I asked the parents and they said the dotor felt it was ADD or ADHD and that s/he prescribed meds. I explained the difference in behaviour and we talked ofen. Within a month they had taken the student off. He was back to himself again. Over a break the doctor told them that I didn't really see what I saw and that they should put him back on the meds and not tell me. Three weeks later when I asked them if everything was okay they told me what the doctor said. This student is now WELL behind, with poor self confidence etc... He has parents and teachers who really care about him, but a doctor who didn't listen and parents who didn't know where to go. What this student needed was an opportuntiy for the "system" to help him and he didn't get it. True-this is one story, but too often we see kids of every age given labels that really don't match (granted I am sooooo not a doctor) and on meds for things that can be treated without drugs. Now medication can be VERY useful and I don't want to diminish the need for those who do need it. We as parents try to advocate for our children, but we need to know what to advocate for, who to trust and where we can go. We have options that we've never before had to research and network and GET that information. I think you make a great point about the "blame the parents" s

    Report Abuse

LEAVE YOUR COMMENT
character(s) remaining

You must sign in to leave a comment

TODAY ON YAHOO!

Top stories

An anti-government demonstrator watches riot police after they clashed outside the metropolitan police headquarters in Bangkok October 7, 2008. REUTERS/Adrees Latif


Uneasy calm in Bangkok after day of deadly riots
Reuters - BANGKOK (Reuters) - An uneasy calm settled over the Thai capital on Wednesday after the...

Business

General view of the Tema oil refinery near Ghana's capital Accra in this file photo from March 28, 2005. REUTERS/Yaw Bibini


Oil back below $90 on demand worries
Reuters - SINGAPORE (Reuters) - Oil prices retreated below $90 a barrel on Wednesday as...

Entertainment

Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band perform at Veterans Park in celebration of the 105th anniversary of Harley-Davidson motorcycles in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, August 30, 2008. REUTERS/Allen Fredrickson


Bruce Springsteen sings for Obama in Michigan
Reuters - YPSILANTI, Michigan (Billboard) - Bruce Springsteen concluded his three-day barnstorming...